Newtonpedia ES
Home › Mathematics › Jones polynomial
Mathematics · 1984

Jones polynomial

A knot invariant that assigns a Laurent polynomial to each knot or link, discovered by Vaughan Jones in 1984.

Year
1984
People involved
Vaughan Jones
Section
Mathematics

History

The Jones polynomial is a polynomial associated with mathematical knots and links, that is, closed loops tangled in space. Its value does not change when the knot is deformed without cutting it, so it can tell different knots apart and help decide whether two diagrams represent the same knot. Vaughan Jones discovered it in 1984, and its importance lies in the unexpected route by which it appeared, from the study of operator algebras, and in how quickly it connected to other areas of physics and mathematics.

Before Jones, knot theory had invariants such as the Alexander polynomial, introduced in 1928, which helped classify knots but did not always distinguish them. Louis Kauffman had developed the bracket polynomial, a tool that assigns an algebraic expression to each knot diagram by combining its crossings according to smoothing rules. Jones came at the problem from a different direction. He studied a particular representation of braid groups inside an algebra that had arisen while analysing statistical mechanics models such as the Potts model. A braid is a set of strands that twist around each other with fixed endpoints, and a theorem of Alexander states that every link can be obtained by closing a suitable braid. By taking a kind of trace of that representation, Jones obtained an invariant that, after normalisation, turned out to match Kauffman's bracket under a change of variable.

The bracket definition relies on a simple adjustment. The bracket changes in a predictable way under a Reidemeister move of type I, which adds or removes a curl in the diagram. To cancel that change, one introduces a factor based on the writhe of the diagram, defined as the number of positive crossings minus the number of negative ones. The writhe alone is not an invariant, but combined with the bracket it produces a quantity that is. Substituting the variable A with t to the power of minus one quarter then yields the Jones polynomial in the variable t to the one half, with integer coefficients.

Soon after its appearance the polynomial was linked to other theories. Edward Witten showed that it can be derived from Chern-Simons theory, a framework of theoretical physics that assigns values to curves in three dimensions. Later, Maxim Kontsevich built an integral that gathers finite type invariants and reproduces the Jones polynomial. In 2000 Mikhail Khovanov defined a homology for knots whose Euler characteristic matches the Jones polynomial, giving rise to Khovanov homology. Kronheimer and Mrowka also proved that no nontrivial knot has the same Khovanov homology as the unknot.

As an invariant, the Jones polynomial is not complete: there are distinct knots with the same polynomial, and whether a nontrivial knot can share it with the unknot remains an open question. Work by Morwen Thistlethwaite shows that there are nontrivial links with the same polynomial as their unlinked counterparts. Today the Jones polynomial is used in topology, in the study of physical systems with symmetries, and in molecular biology, where it helps describe the tangling of DNA. It remains one of the most useful tools for classifying knots.

Timeline

  • 1928James Alexander introduces the Alexander polynomial, one of the first knot invariants.
  • 1984Vaughan Jones discovers the polynomial that bears his name while studying operator algebras.
  • 1987Morwen Thistlethwaite proves that the Jones polynomial of an alternating link is alternating.
  • 2000Mikhail Khovanov constructs a homology for knots whose Euler characteristic is the Jones polynomial.

Trivia and anecdotes

Non-trivial knot with the same polynomial

No nontrivial knot is known to share the Jones polynomial of the unknot. Nontrivial links with the same polynomial as their unlinked counterparts do exist.

11-crossing knots that cannot be told apart

The Conway knot and the Kinoshita-Terasaka knot, both with 11 crossings, share the same Jones polynomial and need other invariants to be told apart.

People involved

Other milestones in Mathematics