Newtonpedia ES
Home › Biology › Tautavel Man
Tautavel Man
Image: Wikimedia Commons
Biology · 1971

Tautavel Man

A set of Middle Pleistocene hominin fossils from the Caune de l'Arago cave in southern France, central to debates about early European humans.

Year
1971
People involved
Henry de Lumley, Marie-Antoinette de Lumley
Section
Biology

History

Tautavel Man is the name given to more than 80 hominin fossil fragments found in the Caune de l'Arago, a limestone cave in Tautavel, in the eastern Pyrenees of France. It matters because it provides one of the richest records of archaic humans who lived in Europe before the Neanderthals, and because its exact place in the human family tree is still debated. Its age is usually given as roughly 450,000 years, though sources vary, placing the remains anywhere between about 550,000 and 400,000 years ago.

The cave was known for animal remains long before any human fossils turned up. In 1828 the French geologist Marcel de Serres reported animal bones that he considered antediluvian, meaning older than the Great Flood of the biblical chronology. In 1963 stone tools were recovered there, which encouraged the French archaeologist Henry de Lumley to keep digging for human remains. He found them in 1964, and on 22 July 1971 he recovered the first face, known as Arago 21. That same year he and his wife, Marie-Antoinette de Lumley, formally described the material and dated it to the Riss glaciation, which predates the European Neanderthals. A parietal bone, Arago 47, was found eight years later and is considered likely to belong to the same individual.

The remains belonged to a male of about twenty years old, roughly 1.65 metres tall, with a flat, sloping forehead and prominent brow ridges. His braincase held about 1,150 cubic centimetres, a volume at the low end of the modern human range. The jawbones, including one from a woman of about fifty and another from a young adult, allow comparisons between the sexes and show large teeth for their period. In shape, the skull resembles Homo erectus more than Homo heidelbergensis, although reconstructions made in the 1980s by several researchers pointed towards heidelbergensis. In 2015 Marie-Antoinette de Lumley redescribed the material and proposed treating it as a distinct, valid subspecies, Homo erectus tautavelensis, using a stricter definition of heidelbergensis.

The stone tools linked to these people belong to traditions called Acheulean or early Tayacian, and hand axes are rare, perhaps because the local stone was hard to shape. Evidence of fire appears only in later layers, around 400,000 years ago, and hearths became common after about 100,000 years ago. These people ate rhinoceros, horse and probably small animals. Some researchers suggest they were scavengers more than hunters, and that they may have practised ritual cannibalism in certain layers. If they did hunt, their range may have covered about 30 kilometres, judging by rocks brought in from elsewhere.

Today Tautavel Man is a key piece in the debate about Middle Pleistocene populations in Europe. Some scientists see it as a European form of Homo erectus, older than the Neanderthals but not necessarily their ancestor. Others place it as a direct ancestor of the Neanderthals within heidelbergensis. Fossils from Ceprano, Galería, Swanscombe, Vértesszőlős and Petralona share features with it, and how they are classified depends on how these species are defined. Comparisons of skulls, jaws and teeth continue to refine the picture of how the human lineage evolved in Europe.

Timeline

  • 1828Marcel de Serres describes animal fossils from the cave, which he considers antediluvian.
  • 1963Stone tools are recovered, prompting Henry de Lumley to search for human remains.
  • 1964Henry de Lumley finds the first human remains in the cave.
  • 1971The face Arago 21 is recovered and the Lumleys formally describe the material.
  • 1979The Lumleys propose the name Homo erectus tautavelensis for the remains.
  • 1982René David completes the first reconstruction of the skull, overseen by Marie-Antoinette de Lumley.
  • 2015Marie-Antoinette de Lumley redescribes the material and treats it as a valid subspecies.

Trivia and anecdotes

A very talkative brain

In 1983 the American anthropologist Ralph Holloway concluded, from the shape of the skull, that the individual was very talkative. In 2004 he admitted that this had been pure speculation.

Bones older than the Flood

The first fossils from the cave were described in 1828 as antediluvian remains, an idea now outdated that reflected the biblical chronology of the time.

Other milestones in Biology