Zeroth law of thermodynamics
A law of thermodynamics stating that if two systems are each in thermal equilibrium with a third, they are in thermal equilibrium with each other, which allows temperature to be defined as a shared label.
- Year
- 1931
- Section
- Physics
History
The zeroth law of thermodynamics states that if two systems are each in thermal equilibrium with a third system, they are in thermal equilibrium with each other. Two systems are in thermal equilibrium when they are separated by a wall that lets only heat pass and they no longer exchange heat, and their observable properties stop changing over time. It may look like a truism, but it is the foundation that lets us treat temperature as a property that can be compared between different objects, and it is the idea that makes practical thermometers meaningful.
Before it had a name of its own, thermodynamics already relied on the idea that heat behaves consistently and that temperatures can be compared. During the nineteenth century the first and second laws were established to describe energy and the direction in which natural processes run, and the third law, concerning the behaviour near absolute zero, came later. The reasoning that two bodies in contact with a third must agree with each other was used implicitly in laboratories and in theory. In 1871, James Clerk Maxwell summed up this intuition in the phrase "all heat is of the same kind", meaning that there is no separate class of heat that behaves differently in thermal contact. In 1909, Constantin Carathéodory built a theory of thermodynamics that postulated the existence of walls permeable only to heat. He did not yet call this the zeroth law.
The name came later. Ralph H. Fowler coined the expression "zeroth law of thermodynamics" in the 1930s, while discussing a 1935 textbook by Meghnad Saha and B. N. Srivastava, which expressed the idea in language very similar to that of earlier writers. Fowler and Edward A. Guggenheim presented it as a separate statement in 1936. It is called zeroth because, although it had long been used, it was formalised only after the other three laws had been recognised, and physicists decided to place it before them as a precondition. Mathematically, thermal equilibrium behaves as an equivalence relation: every system is in equilibrium with itself, if A is in equilibrium with B then B is in equilibrium with A, and if A is in equilibrium with B and B with C, then A is in equilibrium with C. Systems therefore fall into families, and each family can be given a numerical label, which is what is called empirical temperature. It is worth noting that the principle allows labels to be assigned but does not say how to measure them on a particular numerical scale; an absolute scale comes from the second law.
In practice, the zeroth law justifies using a reference body, such as a quantity of gas, to calibrate other thermometers. An ideal thermometer is one that does not noticeably alter the state of the system it measures, and the principle guarantees that if two systems give the same reading, placing them in contact will not change either. Today the official definition of temperature is expressed through the kinetic energy of microscopic particles, linked by the Boltzmann constant, but the zeroth law keeps its role in classical thermodynamics and engineering. Every mercury, alcohol, resistance or digital thermometer used to check a fever or control an oven rests on this idea: that there is a shared property that can be compared between different objects without knowing all of their internal details.
Timeline
- 1871James Clerk Maxwell sums up the idea with the phrase "all heat is of the same kind".
- 1909Constantin Carathéodory postulates walls permeable only to heat in his theory of thermodynamics.
- 1931Around this date the principle spreads as a basis of formal thermodynamics, though the name is not yet settled.
- 1935Saha and Srivastava publish a textbook in which the idea appears in language very close to that of earlier authors.
- 1936Fowler and Guggenheim state it as a principle of its own, under the name zeroth law.
Trivia and anecdotes
A trip across the ocean
According to the available accounts, James Joule had to cross the Atlantic to check his thermometers in person so he could compare his results with those of another researcher in England. It shows that the principle allows temperature labels to be assigned, but does not by itself guarantee that two laboratories use the same numerical scale.
All heat is of the same kind
Maxwell used this phrase to express that, in thermal contact, there are no different kinds of heat. His wording reminds us that the principle speaks of a single form of heat transfer between systems.