Newtonpedia ES
Home › Biology › Denisova 11
Biology · 2010

Denisova 11

A fossil of a 13-year-old girl whose mother was Neanderthal and whose father was Denisovan, the first ancient individual found with parents from two distinct human species.

Year
2010
People involved
Svante Pääbo
Section
Biology

History

Denny, also known as Denisova 11, is the fossil of a girl who lived about 90,000 years ago and whose parents belonged to two different groups of ancient humans. Her mother was a Neanderthal and her father a Denisovan, which makes her a first-generation hybrid, meaning a direct child of both groups. Her importance lies in being the first direct evidence, in an ancient individual, that two archaic human groups had offspring together. Before this find, researchers could only infer such mixing from the genetic traces it left in modern populations.

By the time Denny was identified, it was already known that Neanderthals and Denisovans shared the landscape with modern humans and that their genes survive in people today. Neanderthals have been known since the nineteenth century. Denisovans are a group defined from remains found in Denisova Cave, in the Altai Mountains of Siberia. Since 2010, evidence had been piling up for interbreeding between modern and archaic humans. Today most Europeans and Asians carry roughly 2 to 3 percent Neanderthal DNA, and modern Melanesians carry between 4 and 6 percent Denisovan DNA. Still, the specific crossings that produced these traces had never been observed in a single individual.

The fossil is a bone fragment about 2 centimetres long, excavated by Russian archaeologists in 2012 from layer 12 of the East Gallery of the cave. That campaign produced more than 2,000 fragments that could not be identified by eye, and they were stored without being sorted. In 2015, Tom Higham and Katerina Douka decided to test new methods on those bags of bone. They brought the material to the University of Oxford, where Samantha Brown, a master's student, screened more than 2,000 pieces as part of her dissertation. The technique, called ZooMS, relies on the fact that each animal species produces a characteristic pattern of collagen proteins in its bone, so comparing these patterns can separate animals from humans. In this way a fragment labelled DC1227 was identified as belonging to an archaic human. Micro-CT imaging also showed acid etching and pitting on its surface, suggesting that it had passed through the digestive system of an animal, probably a hyena.

Further analysis helped reconstruct the girl. Radiocarbon dating gave an age of more than 50,000 years, and later dating in 2016 placed her death at about 90,000 years ago. The thickness of the bone indicated that she was at least 13 years old. Her mitochondrial DNA, which is passed down only through the mother, was of Neanderthal type. Her nuclear DNA, inherited from both parents, showed an almost equal mix of Neanderthal and Denisovan ancestry. A comparison of her X chromosomes identified her as female. The genetic diversity estimated for her was comparable to that of present-day Africans, which fits with someone who inherited two distinct lineages. Results were published in 2018 by a team led by Viviane Slon and Svante Pääbo at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig.

The study revealed further surprises. Her father also carried some Neanderthal ancestry, which had entered his lineage between 300 and 600 generations before his lifetime, pointing to earlier mixing between the two groups. Her mother was not closely related to the Neanderthals of the same cave. Her genome was closer to that of Neanderthals from Vindija Cave in Croatia, who lived at least 20,000 years later. This suggests that Neanderthals moved from western Europe toward central Eurasia in several waves and met Denisovans repeatedly over tens of thousands of years. The researchers cannot tell whether the mating was consensual or whether Denny was fertile. A 2019 chronology of the cave deposits indicated that several human groups occupied the site between roughly 300,000 and 20,000 years ago, although it is not yet proven that they lived there at the same time.

Denny has changed how scientists describe human evolution. It no longer seems useful to picture it as a straight line or as a tree of separate branches. A better model is a network of related populations that separated for long periods and then met again. Some researchers argue that hybridization was a creative force in the emergence of modern humans, and the question of whether Neanderthals and Denisovans should count as separate species is increasingly debated. In 2019, genetic studies also suggested the presence of an unknown ancestral group in the genomes of modern people, which shows that the picture is still open. For the general public, the main lesson is that our biological history includes encounters and mixing, and part of that inheritance still lives in the DNA of millions of people today.

Timeline

  • 2010Clear evidence of interbreeding between modern and archaic humans during the Middle and early Upper Paleolithic is published.
  • 2012The two-centimetre bone fragment that later proves to be Denny's is excavated at Denisova Cave.
  • 2015Tom Higham and Katerina Douka decide to apply new methods to the thousands of unidentified fragments stored from the cave.
  • 2016Max Planck DNA analyses complete the genome, and dating places the girl at about 90,000 years ago.
  • 2018Results are published confirming the first direct case of parents from two distinct human species.
  • 2019A chronology of the cave deposits places human occupation of the site between roughly 300,000 and 20,000 years ago.

Trivia and anecdotes

One fragment among thousands

Denny's bone sat for years among more than 2,000 unidentified fragments. Its discovery came because new methods made it possible to review that forgotten material.

Traces of digestion

Acid marks on the bone's surface suggest it passed through the digestive system of an animal, probably a hyena, before it was buried.

Science and a little luck

The geneticist Pontus Skoglund described the case as extraordinary, the product of good science and a little luck, and predicted it will soon appear in textbooks.

People involved

Other milestones in Biology