Newtonpedia ES
Home › Scientific instruments › Fizeau–Foucault apparatus
Scientific instruments · 1850

Fizeau–Foucault apparatus

Two nineteenth-century methods, one using a toothed wheel and one a rotating mirror, that measured the speed of light in air and water in a laboratory for the first time.

Year
1850
People involved
Léon Foucault, Hippolyte Fizeau
Section
Scientific instruments

History

The Fizeau–Foucault apparatus is not a single machine but a name sometimes given to two historical instruments used to measure the speed of light. It matters because it turned a question that had been answered mostly by astronomy into a laboratory measurement, and because its results helped settle a long dispute about whether light is made of particles or waves.

Before these experiments, the speed of light was estimated mainly from astronomical observations, such as the timing of eclipses of Jupiter's moons, and it was assumed to be so fast that it seemed almost instantaneous. Hippolyte Fizeau and Léon Foucault had begun as friends and collaborators, working together on daguerreotype photographs of the Sun between 1843 and 1845. In 1845 François Arago suggested they try to measure the speed of light. The idea had roots in a method Charles Wheatstone had devised with a rapidly rotating mirror. Arago saw in it a way to compare light speed in air and in water, a test that could favour either Newton's particle theory or Fresnel's wave theory.

By 1849 the two had quarrelled and went their separate ways. In 1848–49 Fizeau measured the speed of light in air using a toothed wheel with 720 notches. Light passed through a gap, and when the wheel spun fast enough, the next tooth blocked the returning beam. Knowing the rotation rate and the roughly 8 km distance to a mirror, he obtained about 310,000 km/s. That figure is now known to be about five per cent too high, partly because judging the exact moment of darkness by eye was hard.

In 1850 both men produced comparisons of light in air and water, Fizeau with a apparatus built by Louis Breguet and Foucault with a rotating mirror, and Foucault published about seven weeks ahead. Foucault found that light travels more slowly in water, a result seen as a decisive blow to Newton's particle theory, though Newton had explained refraction in a different way. Between 1850 and 1862 Foucault refined his device. A rotating mirror sent the image of a slit to a distant fixed mirror, and because the rotating mirror had moved slightly while the light travelled, the returning image was displaced. Measuring that shift, under a millimetre over paths of about 20 metres, he obtained 298,000 km/s in 1862, within about 0.6 per cent of the modern value. He was then working at the Paris Observatory under Urbain Le Verrier, who needed the figure for the astronomical unit.

Between 1872 and 1876 Marie Alfred Cornu repeated the toothed wheel experiment at the observatory's request, over a path nearly three times longer. He used an electric chronograph and a telegraph key to record the moments of extinction, averaged readings taken on either side of the minimum, and obtained about 300,400 km/s. Later, Albert Michelson refined the mirror method between 1877 and 1931. Together these measurements narrowed the value steadily and paved the way for the modern figure of 299,792 km/s.

Their lasting impact is largely methodological. They showed that a very fast quantity could be measured in a laboratory using carefully controlled times, distances and rotation rates, an approach that still underpins modern metrology. The speed of light now defines the metre, and the question these instruments helped sharpen about the nature of light was eventually answered by quantum physics and by Einstein's work early in the twentieth century.

Timeline

  • 1838Arago publishes a proposal to compare the speed of light in air and water.
  • 1843Fizeau and Foucault work together on daguerreotype photographs of the Sun, until 1845.
  • 1849Fizeau publishes his toothed wheel measurement of about 310,000 km/s.
  • 1850Fizeau and Foucault compare light in air and water, with results favouring the wave theory.
  • 1862Foucault obtains about 298,000 km/s with his rotating mirror, within 0.6 % of the modern value.
  • 1876Cornu concludes his toothed wheel experiments, with about 300,400 km/s.
  • 1931Michelson completes his rotating mirror measurements, begun in 1877.

Trivia and anecdotes

Two friends turned rivals

Fizeau and Foucault were friends and collaborators before competing for the same measurement. Fizeau commissioned his apparatus from Breguet while Foucault worked independently.

A wheel spun at 41 turns a second

Fizeau's wheel was driven by falling weights and reached a top speed just under 41 turns per second.

People involved

Other milestones in Scientific instruments