
Oil drop experiment
Experiment by Robert Millikan and Harvey Fletcher that measured the elementary electric charge, the charge of the electron, by observing charged oil droplets suspended between two metal plates.
- Year
- 1909
- Section
- Physics
History
The oil drop experiment is a setup with which Robert Millikan and Harvey Fletcher measured the elementary electric charge, the charge carried by a single electron. It matters for two reasons: it gave a precise value for that charge, and it showed directly that electricity does not flow continuously but comes in fixed amounts.
At the end of the nineteenth century, most physicists explained electricity and magnetism by assuming that charge was a continuous quantity, much as many properties of light are explained by treating it as a smooth wave. In 1897, J. J. Thomson, studying cathode rays, identified negatively charged particles he called corpuscles, with a mass about 1/1837 that of a hydrogen atom. George FitzGerald and Walter Kaufmann had found similar results. Even so, not everyone accepted that subatomic particles existed.
Millikan had been working since 1908 at the University of Chicago. With the significant help of Fletcher, and after improving the apparatus, he published first results in 1910 and his main study in 1913. Contradictory observations by Felix Ehrenhaft led to a dispute between the two physicists. Much later, papers found after Fletcher's death described pressure from Millikan for Fletcher to give up authorship, in return for support for his career at Bell Labs. The episode remains debated.
The apparatus had a pair of horizontal, parallel metal plates held apart by a ring of insulating material. Applying a potential difference between them created a uniform electric field. A fine mist of oil droplets was sprayed into the chamber above the plates. The oil was of a type used in vacuum equipment, because it had an extremely low vapour pressure and would not evaporate under the heat of the light source. Some droplets picked up charge through friction with the nozzle; others could be charged by an ionizing source, such as an X-ray tube.
The method had two stages. First the field was switched off and the speed of a falling drop was measured until it reached terminal velocity, the point where air resistance balances its weight. Stokes' law links that drag to the drop's radius, and since the density of the oil was known, its apparent weight, after subtracting the upthrust of the air, could be calculated. Then the field was switched on and the voltage raised until the drop rose at a new steady speed. Comparing the two speeds gave the charge without having to balance the forces exactly, which in practice was very hard.
Repeating this with many drops, Millikan and Fletcher found that every charge was a whole-number multiple of a common value, close to 1.59 × 10⁻¹⁹ coulombs, which they proposed was the charge of a single electron. The accepted value today is 1.602176487 × 10⁻¹⁹ C, with uncertainty in the last digits. The gap is under one percent, though by Millikan's own error estimate it is significant.
The work earned Millikan the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1923, partly for this experiment. It also drew criticism. In 1978 historian Gerald Holton pointed out that Millikan had discarded many drops without an apparent reason. Allan Franklin argued that these exclusions did not change the final value but did shrink the statistical error; including all the data would have given an error of about 2 percent. David Goodstein, examining Millikan's original notebooks, concluded that Millikan included only drops with a complete series of observations.
Later experiments gave higher values. Erik Bäcklin, using X-rays in 1928, obtained a higher figure, which Raymond Birge rejected in 1929. Sten von Friesen then used electron diffraction, and the oil drop experiment was repeated, again giving high numbers. By 1937 a value closer to the modern one had been established.
Today the elementary charge is one of the fundamental constants of physics, and since the 2019 revision of the International System of Units its value is fixed exactly by definition. Between 1995 and 2007, automated experiments at SLAC searched for fractionally charged particles and found none after measuring more than 100 million drops. The experiment is still repeated in teaching laboratories, although it is expensive and difficult to do properly.
Timeline
- 1897J. J. Thomson identifies negatively charged corpuscles, precursors of the electron, while studying cathode rays.
- 1908Millikan begins work on the experiment at the University of Chicago.
- 1910First results of the experiment are published.
- 1913Millikan and Fletcher publish their main study on the electron's charge.
- 1923Millikan receives the Nobel Prize in Physics, partly for this experiment.
- 1928Erik Bäcklin obtains a higher value of the elementary charge using X-rays.
- 1937A value of the elementary charge closer to today's is established.
- 2019The revision of the International System fixes the elementary charge's value by definition.
Trivia and anecdotes
Edison, convinced
Thomas Edison, who had considered charge a continuous variable, changed his mind after working with the Millikan and Fletcher apparatus.
Generations of students
Generations of physics students have repeated the experiment, although it is costly and hard to carry out correctly.
Bias in science
In a 1974 address at Caltech, Richard Feynman used this case to illustrate how psychological effects can influence scientific results.