Newtonpedia ES
Home › Astronomy and space › Tychonic system
Astronomy and space · 1588

Tychonic system

Cosmological model proposed by Tycho Brahe in 1588, in which the Earth stays still at the centre, the Sun and Moon revolve around it, and the other five planets orbit the Sun.

Year
1588
People involved
Tycho Brahe
Section
Astronomy and space

History

The Tychonic system is a model of the universe that Tycho Brahe published in 1588. It matters because it tried to keep what Tycho saw as the mathematical strengths of Copernicus's heliocentric system while retaining the physical and philosophical advantages of the older Ptolemaic idea of a motionless Earth at the centre.

Tycho was not the first to combine the two. An ancient tradition, now doubtful, credited Heraclides of Pontus in the 4th century BC with proposing that Mercury and Venus circle the Sun, which in turn circles the Earth. Later, Martianus Capella described a similar arrangement, and Copernicus, who cited him, suggested the other planets might also orbit the Sun. In the 15th century, the Indian astronomer Nilakantha Somayaji of the Kerala school presented a geo-heliocentric model in which all the known planets orbited the Sun. Tycho may have been influenced by contemporaries such as Valentin Naboth and Paul Wittich, though this is not certain.

Tycho's objections were both physical and observational. He admired the mathematics of Copernicus but found it hard to believe that the heavy, sluggish Earth could spin daily and also move in a triple motion. Aristotelian physics, then accepted, held that the heavens were made of a light, unchanging substance called aether, whose natural motion was circular, while Earth and earthly things were heavy and naturally at rest. Tycho accepted that the Earth's rotation could explain the daily rising and setting of the Sun and stars, but he did not think a dense body like the Earth could move that way.

His second argument concerned stellar parallax. If the Earth travelled around the Sun each year, nearby stars should shift their apparent positions over six months. Copernicans answered that the stars were so distant that the shift was too small to see. Tycho replied that such distant stars would have to be enormous to look as large as they do in the sky. Christoph Rothmann, a Copernican astronomer, answered that a Creator could make stars of any size he chose, a reply that blended geometry with theology. Tycho also cited scripture, though he gave it a secondary role and came to rely mostly on scientific arguments.

In Tycho's scheme the Earth stayed at rest, the Sun, Moon and stars circled it, and the five other planets orbited the Sun. Because the motions relative to the Earth matched those in the Copernican model under a change of coordinates, observations of positions alone could not decide between them. After Galileo's observations of the phases of Venus in 1610, the main debate centred on the Copernican and Tychonic versions. Many found Tycho's model more intuitive, since it kept the Earth still, and the old idea of planets moving on nested circles lost its support.

Its reach was considerable. The papal Index of 1616 banned works defending Copernicus, while the Tychonic system remained an acceptable alternative. Jesuit astronomers such as Christopher Clavius taught and spread it in Europe and China. Kepler, using Tycho's observations, showed that planetary orbits are ellipses, producing a modified Copernican system that eventually prevailed. In the 18th century, James Bradley's discovery of stellar aberration confirmed the Earth's motion, and the Tychonic system fell out of scientific use. Today only some geocentrists defend it, in versions with elliptical orbits that reject relativity. Its lasting value is historical: it showed that two different models could describe the same apparent motions, and that choosing between them depended on physics and new observations.

Timeline

  • 350 BCHeraclides of Pontus is credited, in a doubtful tradition, with proposing that Mercury and Venus orbit the Sun.
  • 1501Nilakantha Somayaji presents in his Tantrasamgraha a geo-heliocentric model with all planets orbiting the Sun.
  • 1588Tycho Brahe publishes his system, combining a motionless Earth with planets orbiting the Sun.
  • 1610Galileo observes the phases of Venus, shifting the debate towards the Copernican and Tychonic versions.
  • 1616The papal Index bans works defending Copernicus, but not the Tychonic system.
  • 1758The ban on Copernican books in the Index is lifted.

Trivia and anecdotes

The size of the stars

Tycho calculated that a typical star measured about one arcminute, and it would have to be enormous if it lay as far away as the Copernican system required.

A parallax that took centuries

Stellar parallax is real but so small that it was not detected until 1838, when Friedrich Bessel measured it for 61 Cygni.

People involved

Other milestones in Astronomy and space