Newtonpedia ES
Home › Physics › Roger Bacon
Roger Bacon
Image: Wikimedia Commons

Roger Bacon

English friar, philosopher and scientist who urged the study of nature through experience in the thirteenth century · 1220–1292

Born
1220
Died
June 18, 1292
Country
Kingdom of England
Section
Physics

Extended biography

Origins and training

Roger Bacon was born in England in the early thirteenth century, but the exact year cannot be fixed. Scholars have proposed 1210, 1213, 1214, 1215 and even 1220, so the date given in his record, 1 January 1220, is a convenient approximation. He is usually linked to Ilchester in Somerset, although some accounts place his birth elsewhere. His only firm personal clue comes from a remark he wrote in 1267, saying that forty years had passed since he first learned his letters. If he meant the alphabet, the sum points to a birth around 1220, but some historians think he meant the basic studies that made up the medieval curriculum, which would shift the chronology.

His family seems to have been comfortably off, though under the troubled reign of Henry III they lost much of their property and several relatives were exiled. Bacon studied at Oxford, where he absorbed the works of Aristotle that formed the core of university teaching. There he came under the influence of Robert Grosseteste, the bishop of Lincoln. Grosseteste had probably left the university before Bacon arrived, yet his ideas about experience and mathematics shaped the young scholars who followed him. No evidence shows that Bacon ever gained a doctorate. The title Doctor Mirabilis, by which he is still known, was a tribute bestowed after his death.

In 1241 he travelled to Paris, then the leading intellectual centre of Europe. Teaching of Aristotle had recently been allowed again after a period of bans, and Bacon completed his arts studies and became a teacher in the faculty. In these years he met masters such as Alexander of Hales and William of Auvergne, which gave him first-hand knowledge of the philosophical and theological debates of his day.

A world that sought truth in books

To understand Bacon, it helps to recall how knowledge was gained in the Middle Ages. Truth was thought to be revealed in Scripture and handed on by the Church, so theology was the highest form of learning. To know something meant understanding correctly what the authorities had said, and the usual method was to comment on texts and debate the opinions of earlier masters. Scholars called this reasoning from the word, and Bacon wanted to replace it, at least in part, with reasoning from the things themselves.

Bacon demanded what he called experiment, but the word did not mean what a modern laboratory scientist would mean by it. For him, experience meant direct observation of things, in the spirit of the empeiria that Aristotle had described, together with close study of how light, bodies and natural processes behave. He drew heavily on Arabic optics, especially Alhazen (Ibn al-Haytham), whose treatise on vision circulated in Latin. Bacon used these methods to study light, reflection and the paths of rays, yet he continued to accept many premises inherited from tradition, so he should not be seen as a modern experimental researcher.

This distinction matters because it prevents exaggeration. Bacon moved within scholasticism, and his trust in Aristotle was strong. His originality lay in holding that claims about nature must be tested against observation, and that when results disagreed with what Aristotle had written, the text, not the world, should be questioned.

Friar, quarrels and the great treatises

Around 1247 Bacon returned to Oxford and spent years in intense study, gathering expensive books, which had to be copied by hand, and instruments. By his own account this effort left him physically and mentally exhausted. Around 1253 he took the Franciscan habit, at a time when the Franciscans and the Dominicans were leading theological debate. Alexander of Hales led the Franciscans, while the rival order was represented by Albertus Magnus and Thomas Aquinas.

His contact with university life disappointed him deeply. Bacon claimed that almost none of the professors knew Greek, that Aristotle was read only in poor translations, and that physics was taught through appeals to authority rather than observation. The only master he truly respected was Peter Peregrinus of Maricourt, author of a famous treatise on the magnet, the De Magnete. Bacon attacked Alexander of Hales and other teachers, whom he accused of having learned what they taught and of imposing their views in a dogmatic tone. His combative manner won him enemies and repeated trouble.

In 1256 the scientific branch of the order was placed under Richard of Cornwall, with whom Bacon had quarrelled. Soon afterwards he was sent to a friary in France, where for nearly ten years he could communicate with his colleagues only in writing, since an order rule forbade publishing without special permission. Cardinal Guy de Foulques, who was interested in his ideas, asked him for a full treatise, and when the cardinal became Pope Clement IV he urged Bacon to write it despite the ban. Bacon did so and in 1267 sent the pope his Opus Maius, a work that ranged over grammar, logic, mathematics, physics and moral philosophy. That same year he sent the Opus Minus, a summary of its main ideas, and in 1268 the Opus Tertium. The pope died in 1268, and Bacon lost his principal protector.

Optics, the calendar and gunpowder

The Opus Maius proposed a reform of university study. Bacon wanted subjects such as optics, astronomy, alchemy, agriculture, medicine and a philosophy of science that would guide them to be added to the curriculum. His section on optics is among the best known. He studied the physiology of sight, the way light is reflected and refracted, and how mirrors and lenses work. He relied mainly on the Latin version of Alhazen's treatise, though he also drew on Ptolemy and other Arabic authors. This work helped bring optics into the medieval university course, although credit for that change is shared with others.

He also proposed reforming the calendar. The Julian calendar assumed a year of 365 and a quarter days, which was slightly too long, so over the centuries dates drifted. Bacon calculated that, for this reason, the computed date of Easter had moved forward by nine days since the Council of Nicaea in 325. He suggested dropping one day every 125 years. The reform was not adopted after the death of Clement IV, and the Gregorian calendar of 1582 arrived by another route, though with a similar correction.

Bacon is also remembered as the first in Europe to record the formula of gunpowder, a mixture that had first been invented and described in China. In some of his writings he describes a blend of saltpetre, sulphur and charcoal that bursts with a loud noise and a bright flash when a small object containing it is ignited. Historians debate whether he had seen Chinese fireworks directly, perhaps through Franciscans who travelled to the Mongol realm. A twentieth-century theory claimed that one passage hid a coded recipe, but most historians reject it: the proportions it yielded were useless for fireworks or for firing a gun, and the passage itself is probably not Bacon's.

Alchemy, languages and a unified knowledge

Bacon was also interested in alchemy, which he considered very important, and several alchemical texts have been attributed to him. Many of these attributions are doubtful. A letter on the secret powers of art and nature, which contains formulae and descriptions of flying machines and submarines, is probably a later forgery. Another work, on the vanity of magic, tries to explain by natural causes phenomena that his contemporaries attributed to hidden powers. Bacon still mixed science with a spiritual view of the world, in which understanding nature led to divine wisdom. For him, experience was not merely a technique but a route towards understanding God.

Languages were equally central to his thinking. Bacon knew several languages and complained that the texts of Scripture and of the Greek philosophers reached Latin readers in poor or misread translations. He argued that theologians should learn Hebrew, Greek and Arabic to read the original sources. He wrote grammars of Greek and Hebrew designed as comparisons with Latin, so that a Latin reader would not misunderstand the originals. Some historians of linguistics see in his ideas an early sketch of a universal grammar valid for all human languages, though other scholars point out that his wording is ambiguous.

He also worked with the Secretum Secretorum, a text attributed to Aristotle and addressed to Alexander the Great, which he knew in the Latin translation of Philip of Tripoli. Bacon prepared an edition with an introduction and notes, and he cited it far more often than his contemporaries did. Some authors think that reading it strongly shaped his interest in experience, but Bacon never described such a change as a conversion himself, and the date of his edition is still debated.

Disputed imprisonment and final years

Tradition holds that after the death of Clement IV, Bacon fell out of favour within his order and was imprisoned by the Franciscans, probably around 1278 in Ancona. According to this version, he was punished for spreading Arabic alchemy and for his criticisms of clerical ignorance and immorality, which supposedly encouraged accusations of sorcery. It is said that he remained confined for about ten years until the intervention of an English nobleman secured his release. This story is doubtful. The earliest references to his imprisonment appear long after his death, and several historians think that, if any punishment occurred, it may have been linked to his sympathy for the radical wing of the Franciscans who defended absolute poverty, a theological question rather than a scientific one.

What seems certain is that Bacon later returned to the Franciscan house in Oxford, where he went on studying. His last dated work, the Compendium of the Study of Theology, was completed in 1292, the year of his death, which is traditionally placed at Oxford. That work added little that was new and dealt largely with concerns from the 1260s, which suggests that his final years were more a matter of repetition than of fresh discovery. He left no distinguished disciples and was forgotten for a long time.

The picture of Bacon as a misunderstood martyr is largely a later construction. Recent studies place him more realistically: he was a thinker of his own time, combative and somewhat eccentric, who tried to fit new sources of knowledge into a Christian view of the world. He was not a modern scientist who had arrived centuries early, but a thirteenth-century schoolman with unusually original ideas about method.

Legends and legacy

In the early modern period Bacon became a legendary figure. He was credited with a brazen head that could answer any question, a story found in an anonymous sixteenth-century account and later staged by Robert Greene in a play that proved very popular. In that version the head spoke through demonic power. These legends turned Bacon into a magician who had tricked the devil, a figure far removed from his own writings. An even older tale attributed a necromantic head to Pope Sylvester II, and some scholars believe the Bacon story drew on medieval fascination with automata and clockwork astronomical models.

In the sixteenth century, thinkers such as Giordano Bruno and John Dee presented him as a forerunner of rational science. In the nineteenth century a more heroic image took hold: that of a solitary genius far ahead of his time, who insisted that theories must be checked against sensory data and instruments. This view, which still appears in some popular science books, exaggerates his modernity. Bacon valued experience, but he still trusted Aristotle and held explanations that we now regard as mistaken. Nor was he as isolated as once believed, since he depended on Grosseteste, Peter of Maricourt and other medieval authors.

Interest in him has remained alive. He has appeared in fiction, most famously in Umberto Eco's The Name of the Rose, where William of Baskerville is among his greatest admirers. His name also survives in astronomy: the lunar crater Baco was named in his honour, using the spelling chosen by the German selenographer Johann Heinrich von Mädler, and the asteroid (69312) Rogerbacon also commemorates him. His most lasting legacy is not a machine but his insistence that knowledge of nature should rest on observation and on careful study of languages and texts.

Quotes

“To ask the proper question is half of knowing.”

Citada en LIFE, 8 de septiembre de 1958, p. 73

“The strongest argument proves nothing so long as the conclusions are not verified by experience.”

Opus tertium (c. 1267), cap. 13

“Mathematics is the gate and key of the sciences.”

Citada por Morris Kline en Mathematics and the physical world (1969), p. 1

“To imitate thunder and lightning, mix sulphur, saltpetre and charcoal dust. This mixture enclosed in a tube or hollow instrument ignites on contact with fire, and causes an explosion equal to the crash of thunder and the brilliance of lightning.”

Epistola de Secretis Operibus Artis et Naturae et de Nullitate Magiae, recogido por Eugenio de Tapia en Historia de la civilización española (1840), vol. 1, p. 260

Main contributions

  • 1267Opus Maius: a treatise sent to the pope on grammar, logic, mathematics, physics and philosophy, with a proposal to reform university studies.
  • 1267Calendar reform proposal: he suggested dropping one day every 125 years to correct the drift of the Julian calendar from the solar year.
  • 1267Optical studies on vision, refraction and the behaviour of mirrors and lenses, drawing mainly on the work of Alhazen.
  • 1267One of the first European records of a gunpowder formula, although gunpowder had been invented and described earlier in China.
  • Work on languages, with an early outline of what would later be called universal grammar, though its exact date is not known.

Teachers and students

Trivia and anecdotes

A posthumous nickname

The title Doctor Mirabilis was given to him after his death, and there is no evidence that he ever held a doctorate in life.

The brazen head

In the early modern period he was credited with the legend of a mechanical or magical brazen head that could answer questions, a story with no historical basis.

A lunar crater and an asteroid

The lunar crater Baco, named by the German selenographer Johann Heinrich von Mädler, and the asteroid (69312) Rogerbacon commemorate him.

Their contemporaries

While Roger Bacon was alive (1220–1292)…

Alive at the same time

Discovered or invented in those years

  • 1221
    BombAn explosive device that releases a large amount of energy in a sudden burst.
  • 1232
    RocketA vehicle that moves by expelling gas at high speed, carrying its own propellant so it can work in the vacuum of space.
  • 1250
    Hand cannonAn early firearm: a metal tube closed at one end, loaded with gunpowder and a projectile and lit by hand through a small side hole.
  • 1270
    GlassesAn optical device of two lenses held in a frame that rests on the nose and ears, used mainly to correct vision.
  • 1275
    EscapementA mechanical linkage in clocks and watches that releases the gear train in small, regular steps while giving impulses to the oscillating timekeeper.
  • 1288
    FirearmA device that fires one or more projectiles driven by high-pressure gas from the rapid burning of a chemical propellant.

See this life on the timeline →

Also on our sister sites

More people in Physics