
Stephen Jay Gould
American paleontologist, evolutionary biologist and historian of science, author of the punctuated equilibrium theory · 1941–2002
- Born
- September 10, 1941
- Died
- May 20, 2002
- Country
- United States
- Section
- Biology
Biography
Stephen Jay Gould (Queens, New York, 1941 - New York, 2002) was an American paleontologist, evolutionary biologist and historian of science, and one of the most widely read popular science writers of his generation. He worked in the second half of the twentieth century, when biologists were debating how species change over time. He matters for two reasons: together with Niles Eldredge he proposed a new account of the pace of evolution, and he brought complex scientific arguments to a wide readership through essays and books.
Gould was born in 1941 in Queens and grew up in Bayside, a middle-class neighbourhood in the northeast of the city. His father, Leonard, worked as a court stenographer and had served in the United States Navy during the Second World War. His mother, Eleanor, was an artist whose parents were Jewish immigrants who worked in the Garment District. He had a younger brother, Peter. He attended P.S. 26 and graduated from Jamaica High School. The story most often told about his vocation dates from when he was five, when his father took him to the dinosaur hall of the American Museum of Natural History and he first saw a Tyrannosaurus rex. He later said he had no idea such things existed and was astonished. He decided that day to become a paleontologist.
He was raised in a secular Jewish household. He did not practise any religion and preferred to be called an agnostic. Although he had been brought up by a Marxist father, he said his own political views were very different from his father's, and that they tended to the left of centre. Among the political books that shaped him, he named C. Wright Mills's The Power Elite and the political writings of Noam Chomsky.
His education was varied. He studied at Antioch College in Yellow Springs, Ohio, graduating in 1963 with a double major in geology and philosophy. In those years he took part in the civil rights movement. He also spent time at the University of Leeds in England, where he organised weekly demonstrations outside a Bradford dance hall that refused to admit black people, and kept them going until the policy was dropped. He completed graduate work at Columbia University in 1967 under the supervision of Norman Newell. That same year Harvard hired him, and he stayed there for the rest of his life. In 1973 he was promoted to professor of geology and curator of invertebrate palaeontology at Harvard's Museum of Comparative Zoology.
His best-known contribution is the theory of punctuated equilibrium, which he developed with Eldredge in 1972. According to the fossil record, species tend to remain stable for long stretches, and major change happens in short bursts when new species appear. This challenged phyletic gradualism, the older picture of evolution as a slow and smooth process. Gould coined the name, although Eldredge first presented the idea in his doctoral dissertation on Devonian trilobites. Gould believed the idea revised a key pillar of Darwinian logic, while other biologists argued it only refined neo-Darwinism. Much of his field research focused on land snails: first the Bermudian genus Poecilozonites, and later Cerion, from the Caribbean. Cerion has hundreds of described forms, which Gould saw as a striking range of shapes arising from very small genetic differences.
Gould also made important contributions to evolutionary developmental biology. In Ontogeny and Phylogeny he examined heterochrony, changes in the timing of developmental stages. He described neoteny, in which development slows and the organism keeps juvenile traits, and terminal addition, in which the final stages of development are extended. His ideas still shape research, including work on the evolution of feathers.
With the palaeontologist Elisabeth Vrba he coined the term exaptation, for a trait that arises for one function and is later used for another. He also argued that many higher capacities of the human brain might be by-products of natural selection rather than direct adaptations. This put him at odds with human sociobiology. In 1975, his Harvard colleague E. O. Wilson presented an analysis of behaviour from that perspective. Gould, Richard Lewontin and other Boston-area scientists answered with an open letter to The New York Review of Books titled Against Sociobiology, which criticised what they saw as a deterministic view of human society. Yet Gould did not reject sociobiological explanations for all animal behaviour.
In 1979, with Lewontin, he published The Spandrels of San Marco and the Panglossian Paradigm. A spandrel is the curved triangular space between an arch and a dome. During a visit to Venice in 1978, Gould noticed that the spaces in the basilica of San Marco were not planned by the architect but arose as an unavoidable result of placing a dome on arches. He transferred the image to biology to describe traits that arise as side effects of other traits rather than by direct selection. He criticised what he called the Panglossian paradigm, named after Dr Pangloss in Voltaire's Candide, who insists that everything is for the best. How common such traits are remains a debated question.
Gould also argued that evolution does not climb a ladder toward greater complexity. Life begins in simple forms, and the diversification that follows has no fixed direction, which can look like progress. Many lineages simplify instead, as parasites do. In a review of Full House, Richard Dawkins largely agreed, though he thought some lineages did show a cumulative trend toward more complex adaptations.
Gould defended the separation of science and religion. He proposed that they are distinct spheres, or magisteria, whose authorities do not overlap, and he campaigned against creationism. His essays for Natural History, later collected in books such as Dinosaur in a Haystack and The Panda's Thumb, gave him a very large audience. In Wonderful Life he read the fossils of the Cambrian Burgess Shale as evidence of a great variety of body plans and of the role of chance in which lineages survive.
In his personal life he married the artist Deborah Lee in 1965, and they had two sons, Jesse and Ethan. In 1995 he married the sculptor Rhonda Roland Shearer. In 1982 he was diagnosed with peritoneal mesothelioma, a deadly abdominal cancer linked to asbestos exposure. After a difficult recovery he wrote the 1985 column The Median Isn't the Message for Discover magazine. In it he explained that the median survival after diagnosis was eight months, and that this figure meant half of patients lived longer, which he hoped placed him among them. During treatment he smoked marijuana to ease nausea, and he considered it important to his recovery. In 1998 he testified in the case of the Canadian activist Jim Wakeford, who sought the right to use marijuana for medical purposes.
In February 2002 a lesion was found and he was diagnosed with advanced cancer. He died on 20 May 2002 at his SoHo home from an adenocarcinoma of the lung that had spread to his brain. That cancer was unrelated to the abdominal cancer he had survived twenty years earlier.
His legacy includes the presidency of the American Association for the Advancement of Science (1999-2001), the presidency of the Paleontological Society (1985-1986), his election to the National Academy of Sciences in 1989, and, posthumously, the Darwin-Wallace Medal in 2008. He remains one of the most cited authors in evolutionary theory and a model of how to explain evolution without oversimplifying it.
Main contributions
- 1972Punctuated equilibrium, developed with Niles Eldredge: evolution alternates long periods of stability with sudden bursts that produce new species.
- 1975The open letter Against Sociobiology, criticising the deterministic view of human behaviour defended by E. O. Wilson.
- 1979The essay The Spandrels of San Marco and the Panglossian Paradigm, which brought the term spandrel into biology for traits arising as side effects.
- 1985The column The Median Isn't the Message in Discover magazine, on the meaning of survival statistics after his diagnosis.
- 2002The Structure of Evolutionary Theory, his large treatise on evolutionary theory, published shortly before his death.
Teachers and students
Trivia and anecdotes
The childhood dinosaur
He recalled that his vocation began at the age of five, in front of a Tyrannosaurus rex skeleton at the American Museum of Natural History.
Evolution by creeps
Some critics joked that punctuated equilibrium was evolution by jerks. Gould replied by describing gradualism as evolution by creeps.
A snail with hundreds of names
The genus Cerion has 600 described species, though Gould pointed out that they interbreed and the names mainly capture its remarkable variety of shapes.
Their contemporaries
While Stephen Jay Gould was alive (1941–2002)…
Alive at the same time
Discovered or invented in those years
- 1945ComputerA programmable machine that takes in data, processes it by following stored instructions, and produces results, able to switch tasks simply by running different software.
- 1957Artificial satelliteAn artificial satellite is a human-made object placed in orbit around a celestial body, usually Earth, to collect information, relay signals, or carry out a specific task.
- 1969InternetA global network of interconnected computer networks that communicate using the TCP/IP protocol suite.
- 1971EmailA network service that lets users send and receive digital messages through addressed mailboxes, much like postal mail but electronic.
- 1973Mobile phoneA handheld wireless phone that lets people make and receive calls while moving across a cellular network area.
- 1989World Wide WebA system of linked documents and resources, connected by hyperlinks and accessed over the Internet with web browsers.
Christiane Nüsslein-Volhard1942 · Biology
Ada Yonath1939–2026 · Biology
Kary Mullis1944–2019 · Biology
Lynn Margulis1938–2011 · Biology
Yoshinori Ohsumi1945 · Biology
Françoise Barré-Sinoussi1947 · Biology