
Analog computer
A machine that solves problems by representing quantities with continuously varying physical magnitudes, such as rotations, lengths, electrical voltages or fluid pressures.
- Year
- 1940
- Section
- Computing
History
An analog computer solves a problem by reproducing the behaviour of the system under study with physical quantities that change continuously, such as a length, a rotation, an electrical voltage or the pressure of a liquid. Instead of counting symbols, the device imitates the system it studies, and the answer is read by measuring that quantity. It matters because for centuries it was one of the fastest ways to calculate motions, trajectories or tides, and many ideas that still shape control engineering come from it.
Before the twentieth century, aids to analog calculation were hand-operated or mechanical instruments. The Antikythera mechanism, found in 1901 in a shipwreck off the Greek island of Antikythera, is considered by some historians the earliest known mechanical analog computer, although its exact date of manufacture is uncertain. In the Islamic world, the astrolabe and the so-called castle clock of Al-Jazari, dated 1206, showed the movement of the heavens and could be reprogrammed. In early modern times, the slide rule, invented around 1620 to 1630 shortly after the concept of the logarithm was published, let users multiply and divide by sliding one scale against another.
The great mechanical leap came with the differential analyser. Its principle is simple: a disc that moves across a ball transmits a rotation depending on its position, and that travel is equivalent to integration, that is, to adding up small quantities continuously. In this way it could solve differential equations. James Thomson described the idea in 1876, and others developed it later. Leonardo Torres Quevedo built several machines for finding the roots of polynomials, and Michelson and Stratton designed a harmonic analyser that performed Fourier analysis with an array of 80 springs. By 1912, Arthur Pollen had built an electrically driven mechanical analog computer for fire control, based on the differential analyser, which was used by the Imperial Russian Navy during the First World War.
The 1930s and 1940s were the years of its greatest practical use. Around 1936, Vladimir Lukiyanov developed in the Soviet Union a water integrator that solved differential equations through the flow of a liquid; it was first used to calculate concrete structures and stayed in service until 1984. During the Second World War, gun aimers and bomb sights relied on mechanical analog computers, which were made in large numbers. The catalogue entry dates the device to around 1940, a date that sums up this period well. In 1942, Helmut Holzer built at Peenemunde a fully electronic analog computer to calculate the trajectories of V-2 rockets from accelerations and orientations.
After the war, electronics replaced gears. An operational amplifier and a few passive components can imitate a mass-spring system: the simulated mass is changed by turning a potentiometer, and measurements are taken directly with an oscilloscope. This model was cheaper, safer and easier to modify than building the physical system, and it could run faster than real time. Its limits were precision, usually three or four significant digits, the range over which signals can vary, and noise. Digital computers, which handle discrete symbols, gained ground from the 1950s and 1960s, yet analog machines survived in flight simulators and in teaching control theory. Hybrid machines combined both: the analog part gave a rough first value and the digital part refined it through many iterations.
Today the analog principle has not disappeared. Mechanical watches still rely on gears turning continuously, and analog simulation remains part of circuit and control system design.
Timeline
- 1206Al-Jazari builds the castle clock, a programmable astronomical clock regarded as the first programmable analog computer.
- 1620Around 1620 to 1630 the slide rule is invented, a hand tool for multiplying and dividing.
- 1872William Thomson creates a tide predictor that uses pulleys and wires to calculate tide levels.
- 1876James Thomson proposes the differential analyser, a mechanical device for solving differential equations by integration.
- 1912Arthur Pollen develops a mechanical analog computer for fire control, based on the differential analyser.
- 1936Vladimir Lukiyanov develops the water integrator in the Soviet Union to solve differential equations.
- 1942Helmut Holzer builds at Peenemunde a fully electronic analog computer to calculate V-2 rocket trajectories.
- 1949The MONIAC, a hydraulic model of a national economy, is unveiled for the first time.
Trivia and anecdotes
A clock with music
Al-Jazari's castle clock included five robotic musicians who played when levers driven by a cam shaft struck them. Its day and night length could also be reprogrammed each day to follow the changing seasons.
A navy instrument
The Dumaresq, invented around 1902 by Lieutenant John Dumaresq of the Royal Navy, linked fire control variables to the movement of the ship and of a target ship. Several increasingly complex versions were produced.
A low-cost teaching kit
The Heathkit EC-1, made around 1960 by the Heath Company, was an educational analog computer that cost 199 dollars and was programmed with patch cords connecting nine operational amplifiers.