Newtonpedia ES
Home › Scientific instruments › Cloud chamber
Cloud chamber
Image: Wikimedia Commons
Scientific instruments · 1911

Cloud chamber

A sealed chamber of vapor kept on the edge of condensation, where the passage of a charged particle shows up as a visible trail of droplets.

Year
1911
People involved
Charles Thomson Rees Wilson
Section
Scientific instruments

History

A cloud chamber, also known as a Wilson chamber, is an instrument that makes the paths of particles visible, particles that cannot be seen directly, such as those given off by radioactive atoms or those arriving from space as cosmic rays. Its importance lies in allowing scientists, for the first time, to watch the track of particles that had previously been known only through indirect effects. The basic idea is simple. Inside a sealed space, vapor sits close to the point where it would condense. When an electrically charged particle crosses it, the particle knocks electrons off gas molecules, leaving behind charged atoms called ions. These ions act as seeds, and tiny droplets form along their path, drawing the route the particle has taken.

Before Wilson, radiation was studied mainly with photographic plates, which showed that radiation had been present but not its path, and with electrical counters, which reported how many particles arrived. Researchers knew that air became conductive when radiation passed through it, but they could not follow what happened at each step. Charles Thomson Rees Wilson (1869-1959), a Scottish physicist, became interested in cloud formation and optical effects in moist air while working on the summit of Ben Nevis, Scotland's highest mountain, in 1894. There he was inspired by the Brocken spectre, a giant shadow cast onto mist, and he began building expansion chambers, vessels in which moist air cools when its volume is suddenly increased. He soon noticed that ions in the air could serve as centers where water droplets formed, and he set out to turn that observation into a way of seeing particles.

Wilson perfected the first cloud chamber in 1911. In his original design, the air in the sealed vessel was saturated with water vapor. A diaphragm allowed the air to be expanded suddenly. This adiabatic expansion, meaning expansion without heat being exchanged with the outside, cooled the air and left the vapor in an unstable state, so that when a particle passed, the vapor condensed onto the ions it left behind. Images were recorded on cine film. Later, Patrick Blackett used a stiff spring to expand and compress the chamber very quickly, which made it sensitive to particles several times per second. This version is known as a pulsed chamber, because its operating conditions are not kept constant.

Recognition came in 1927, when Wilson shared the Nobel Prize in Physics. He received half of it, and Arthur Compton received the other half for the effect that bears his name. By then the chamber had already produced decisive results. In 1932 Carl Anderson used it to confirm the positron, a particle with the same mass as the electron but a positive charge, whose existence Paul Dirac had predicted theoretically in 1928. Its track curved in the opposite direction to that of electrons when a magnetic field was applied, which revealed its charge. Cloud chambers were later used to identify the muon in 1936 and the kaon in 1947, always with cosmic rays as the source of particles.

In 1936 Alexander Langsdorf developed the diffusion cloud chamber, which is sensitive all the time rather than only after each expansion. To work, its base must be kept very cold, often with dry ice, and alcohol is used instead of water because its condensation temperature is lower. In this design a warm top plate holds liquid alcohol that evaporates; the vapor sinks, cools, and forms a supersaturated zone near the cold bottom plate. When a particle crosses that zone, alcohol condenses on its ions and forms a visible mist. To make the tracks stand out, a black background and a sideways light are used, and sometimes an electric field that pulls droplets toward the observation area. Because the design is simple, home-built versions exist that let people see secondary cosmic rays.

The cloud chamber lost its central role with the arrival of the bubble chamber, invented by Donald Glaser in 1952, for which he received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1960. Instead of vapor, it uses a superheated liquid, usually liquid hydrogen, in which tracks appear as bubbles. Because a liquid is much denser than a gas, particles interact more often with the material, rare events become more likely to be recorded, and the device recovers more quickly between events. For these reasons, by the early 1960s the bubble chamber had become the dominant detector in fundamental research, and the cloud chamber was largely set aside.

The principle behind the cloud chamber also inspired other detectors. Proportional counters and ionization chambers turn ionization into electrical pulses, which makes individual events easier to analyze. Spark chambers record a path through electrical sparks between plates, and solid-state detectors, such as those made of silicon and germanium, generate electrical charge pairs in a semiconductor. Today these instruments are used in particle physics, astronomy, medicine, and radiation monitoring. The cloud chamber remains a valued teaching tool, but its greatest legacy is having shown that something as ordinary as droplets forming in vapor could open a window onto the subatomic world.

Timeline

  • 1894Wilson begins studying cloud formation and optical effects in moist air while working on Ben Nevis.
  • 1911Wilson perfects the first cloud chamber, based on expanding air saturated with vapor.
  • 1927Wilson receives half of the Nobel Prize in Physics, shared with Arthur Compton.
  • 1932Carl Anderson uses the cloud chamber to confirm the existence of the positron.
  • 1936Alexander Langsdorf develops the diffusion cloud chamber, which is continuously sensitive.
  • 1947George Rochester and Clifford Butler discover the kaon using a cloud chamber as the detector.
  • 1952Donald Glaser invents the bubble chamber, which soon becomes the preferred detector.
  • 1960The cloud chamber is displaced from fundamental research by the bubble chamber.

Trivia and anecdotes

A shadow in the mist

Wilson was inspired by the Brocken spectre, a giant shadow cast onto mist that he saw while working on the summit of Ben Nevis.

A home-built chamber

With household materials and dry ice, or with thermoelectric cooling, it is possible to build a diffusion cloud chamber and see secondary cosmic rays.

Four particles in one picture

A photograph taken at the Pic du Midi, at 2877 meters, shows in a single shot four kinds of particles detectable in this chamber: proton, electron, probably muon, and alpha particle.

People involved

Other milestones in Scientific instruments