Newtonpedia ES
Home › Astronomy and space › Nebular hypothesis
Astronomy and space · 1755

Nebular hypothesis

A model explaining how the Sun, the planets and other bodies formed from a cloud of gas and dust spinning around the young star.

Year
1755
People involved
Pierre-Simon Laplace
Section
Astronomy and space

History

The nebular hypothesis describes how the Solar System may have been born from a cloud of gas and dust that flattened and condensed into the Sun and the planets. It is today the most widely accepted model for the origin of our planetary system, and its basic idea is thought to apply to other stars with planets as well. Its core logic is simple: a spinning cloud that contracts under its own gravity ends up with a hot centre surrounded by a disk, and the material in that disk gradually clumps into ever larger bodies.

Before the model took shape, the notion that celestial bodies came from gas clouds had philosophical roots. Emanuel Swedenborg proposed parts of the idea in 1734, but the fuller version is usually credited to Immanuel Kant, who published it in 1755 in his Universal Natural History and Theory of the Heavens. Kant argued that slowly rotating gaseous clouds, or nebulae, would flatten under gravity and eventually form stars and planets. Pierre-Simon Laplace independently proposed a similar model in 1796, in his Exposition of the System of the World. He imagined an extended hot solar atmosphere that, as it cooled and contracted, spun faster and shed rings of material from which the planets condensed. His version dominated thinking through the 19th century.

The Laplacian model ran into a serious obstacle involving angular momentum, a measure of how much a system spins. The planets hold about 99 percent of it, and the model could not account for that. By the early 20th century most astronomers had abandoned it. Several alternatives followed, including Thomas Chamberlin and Forest Moulton's planetesimal theory, James Jeans's tidal model and Otto Schmidt's accretion model, but none fully succeeded. In 1978 Andrew Prentice revived Laplace's ideas in a modern form.

The decisive shift came with the Soviet astronomer Victor Safronov, whose 1969 book, translated into English in 1972, set out nearly all the major problems of planet formation and solved some of them. His work led to the solar nebular disk model, the modern standard. George Wetherill extended these ideas and described runaway accretion, a process in which growth speeds up as bodies get bigger. Today it is understood that stars are born in giant molecular clouds that break up and collapse, and each young star is surrounded by a protoplanetary disk of gas and dust. In that disk, dust grains stick together into kilometre-sized bodies and then into planetary embryos. Embryos close to the star merge into rocky planets, while beyond the frost line, where ice dominates, cores can grow large enough to capture huge amounts of gas and become giant planets.

The model accounts well for many features of the Solar System, such as the nearly circular orbits, the near alignment of those orbits and the direction in which the planets revolve. Open questions remain. It is not fully understood how the disk sheds the angular momentum that lets material fall inward, nor how centimetre-sized grains become kilometre-sized planetesimals. It is also unclear why some stars have planets and others do not. Even so, the nebular hypothesis has shaped how astronomers understand planetary origins, including the more than a thousand extrasolar planets known by 2014, and it remains the reference framework for planetary science today.

Timeline

  • 1734Emanuel Swedenborg proposes elements of the idea that celestial bodies arise from gas clouds.
  • 1755Immanuel Kant publishes Universal Natural History and Theory of the Heavens, with a detailed version of the model.
  • 1796Pierre-Simon Laplace presents his own version in the Exposition of the System of the World.
  • 1901Chamberlin and Moulton propose the planetesimal theory as an alternative to Laplace's model.
  • 1972Victor Safronov's book appears in English, laying the foundations of the solar nebular disk model.
  • 2014More than eighteen hundred extrasolar planets have been discovered in our galaxy.

Trivia and anecdotes

Laplace's fall

For much of the 19th century Laplace's model was the most accepted, but its failure to explain angular momentum pushed it aside in the early 20th century.

A criticism attributed to Maxwell

Some sources credit James Clerk Maxwell with an objection to the theory, but later research deemed the attribution incorrect, with the error traced to George Gamow.

People involved

Other milestones in Astronomy and space