
Luis Walter Alvarez
American experimental physicist, inventor of the liquid hydrogen bubble chamber and 1968 Nobel laureate in Physics · 1911–1988
- Born
- June 13, 1911
- Died
- September 1, 1988
- Country
- United States
- Section
- Physics
- Awards
- Nobel Prize in Physics
Extended biography
Early life and training
Luis Walter Alvarez was born in San Francisco, California, on June 13, 1911, into a Catholic family. He was the second child and the eldest son of Walter C. Alvarez, a physician, and Harriet Smyth. His paternal grandfather, Luis F. Alvarez, had been born in Asturias, Spain, had spent some time in Cuba, and then settled in the United States, where he found a more effective way to diagnose macular leprosy. Luis had an older sister, a younger brother and a younger sister. His aunt, Mabel Alvarez, was a California painter.
In 1926 his father took a research post at the Mayo Clinic, and the family moved to Rochester, Minnesota, where Luis finished high school. He had always assumed he would study at the University of California, Berkeley, but on the advice of his teachers he went to the University of Chicago instead. He received his bachelor's degree there in 1932, his master's in 1934 and his doctorate in 1936.
He discovered physics almost by accident. At Chicago he had the rare chance, for an undergraduate, to work with equipment once used by the physicist Albert Michelson. Under the supervision of Arthur Compton he built a cosmic ray telescope from Geiger counters, devices that register electrically charged particles, and took it to Mexico City to measure what was called the East-West effect. Cosmic rays are particles from space that strike the upper atmosphere. Alvarez found more radiation arriving from the west, and concluded that most of these primary rays carried a positive charge. The paper appeared with his name first, an early sign of his experimental skill.
His father had been a deacon in a Congregational church, but Alvarez described himself as an agnostic. This difference did not prevent him from remaining close to his family for the rest of his life.
The Berkeley years
When he finished his oral examinations, Alvarez was engaged to Geraldine Smithwick. His sister Gladys worked part-time as a secretary for the physicist Ernest Lawrence at Berkeley, and she told Lawrence about her brother. Lawrence invited him to tour an exhibition in Chicago and soon afterwards offered him a job at the Radiation Laboratory. A telegram carrying the offer began a relationship with the University of California that lasted for decades.
At the laboratory he joined Lawrence's experimental group, supported by theorists led by Robert Oppenheimer. One of his first projects was to observe K-electron capture, a process in which an atomic nucleus absorbs an inner electron. The beta decay theory predicted it, but no one had seen it. To detect it, he used magnets to sweep away the positrons and electrons from his radioactive sources and built a special Geiger counter that responded only to the weak X-rays produced by the capture. He published the results in 1937.
Another significant study concerned fusion between nuclei of deuterium, a heavy form of hydrogen. This reaction can yield either tritium or helium-3, and knowing which of these was stable mattered for understanding the process. Hans Bethe expected tritium to be stable and helium-3 to be unstable. Alvarez showed the opposite. He adjusted the 60-inch cyclotron to accelerate helium-3 nuclei, obtained a beam of them, and in effect used the machine as a very powerful mass spectrometer, a device that sorts particles by their mass. He then produced radioactive tritium and measured how long it lasted.
In 1938 he developed what are now called time-of-flight techniques, which sort particles by how fast they travel, and used them to produce an almost single-energy beam of slow neutrons. With the physicist Felix Bloch he measured the magnetic moment of the neutron, a property describing how the particle behaves in a magnetic field. Their result, published in 1940, was a major improvement on earlier measurements.
Radar during the war
In 1940 a British mission to the United States, the Tizard Mission, showed American scientists the cavity magnetron, a device that could generate short pulses of very short-wavelength radar. The American government then set up a central laboratory at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology to develop military uses of microwave radar. Lawrence recommended his best cyclotron specialists, Alvarez among them, and Alvarez joined the new Radiation Laboratory on November 11, 1940.
His work covered a wide range of problems. He helped improve identification friend or foe beacons, small devices that answer a radar signal and let operators tell their own aircraft from enemy ones. Today such devices are called transponders. He also contributed to a system called VIXEN, designed to stop enemy submarines noticing that they had been spotted by new airborne radars. Submarines usually waited for the radar signal to grow strong before diving. VIXEN transmitted a signal whose strength rose with the cube of the distance to the submarine. As the aircraft approached, the signal the submarine received grew weaker, so the crew assumed the plane was moving away and did not dive.
One of his best-known inventions was a linear dipole array antenna for the Microwave Early Warning system. The antenna reduced side lobes, which are unwanted emissions in directions the radar does not need, and it could be steered electronically without moving any parts. It was the first microwave phased-array antenna, and the principle later spread widely. The same antenna was used in the Eagle precision bombing radar, which was finished late in the war and arrived too late to make much difference.
The system for which Alvarez is best remembered is Ground Controlled Approach, or GCA. Using his antenna to achieve very fine angular resolution, operators on the ground watched precision displays that tracked a landing aircraft and radioed instructions to its pilot. The method was simple and worked even with pilots who had little training for it. Armed forces kept using it for years after the war, and in some countries it was still in service in the 1980s. In 1945 he received the Collier Trophy, an American aviation award, for his role in conceiving and developing the system.
In the summer of 1943 he spent time in England testing GCA, guiding back planes that had flown in bad weather, and training British personnel to use it. There he met Arthur C. Clarke, a young RAF radar technician, and the two became lasting friends. Clarke drew on the experience for his novel Glide Path, in which a thinly disguised version of Alvarez appears.
The Manhattan Project and Hiroshima
In the autumn of 1943 Oppenheimer offered him a post at Los Alamos on the Manhattan Project. First, however, Alvarez spent a few months in Chicago working with Enrico Fermi. Meanwhile General Leslie Groves asked him to find a way for the United States to learn whether Germany was operating nuclear reactors and where they were. Alvarez proposed that an aircraft carry equipment to detect radioactive gases released by reactors, especially xenon-133. The team flew over Germany and found nothing, because the Germans had not built a reactor able to sustain a chain reaction. The idea of monitoring fission products from the air became an important intelligence tool after the war.
He reached Los Alamos in the spring of 1944. Design of the uranium bomb, called Little Boy, was already well advanced, so he concentrated mainly on the plutonium bomb, called Fat Man. The uranium design fired two subcritical pieces together like a gun. That would not work with plutonium, which emits neutrons spontaneously at a rate that would set off premature chain reactions, so the material would blow apart before releasing much energy. The solution was to compress a nearly critical plutonium sphere rapidly with explosives into a much smaller, denser core. For the squeeze to be even, thirty-two explosive charges had to detonate almost together, to within a small fraction of a microsecond, which ordinary detonators could not manage.
Alvarez assigned the problem to his graduate student Lawrence H. Johnston. Johnston used a large capacitor to send a high-voltage pulse straight to each explosive lens, replacing the usual blasting caps with exploding-bridgewire detonators, in which a thin wire is vaporized by a surge of current. The charges then fired within a few tenths of a microsecond of one another. The invention was essential to making the implosion design work.
His last task for the project was to design calibrated microphone transmitters that could be dropped by parachute from an aircraft to measure the shock wave of an explosion, and so estimate the energy released. Commissioned as a lieutenant colonel in the Army, he watched the Trinity test from a B-29 bomber.
In August 1945 he flew again, with Johnston, in the B-29 The Great Artiste, which accompanied the Enola Gay on the mission to Hiroshima. From that second aircraft, and using instruments he had designed, the team recorded data that allowed the energy of the explosion to be estimated. A few days later Johnston repeated the measurements over Nagasaki. This role is less known than those of other scientists, but it was a practical contribution of field data. Alvarez later said he did not regret building or using the bomb, a position that differed from that of some of his colleagues. After the war he returned to Berkeley as a full professor and stayed there for the rest of his career.
The bubble chamber and the Nobel Prize
Back at Berkeley, Alvarez had many ideas for applying his radar experience to particle accelerators. Some of them bore fruit, but the major innovation of the period came from Edwin McMillan, whose principle of phase stability led to the synchrocyclotron. Lawrence's team then built the Bevatron, the largest proton accelerator in the world at the time, which began operating in 1954. It produced many interesting particles, but the collisions it caused were hard to detect and analyse.
The answer lay in the bubble chamber, invented by Donald Glaser. A liquid can be held in a superheated state, meaning above its boiling point without boiling. If the pressure is suddenly reduced, the liquid boils along the path of a charged particle passing through it, leaving a trail of bubbles that can be photographed. Glaser's first device used ether and could keep the superheated state for only a few seconds.
Alvarez realised that the chamber would be far more useful if it could be filled with liquid hydrogen. Hydrogen nuclei are single protons, and they make the simplest and most desirable target for the particles produced by the Bevatron. His group built a series of chambers of increasing size, up to 15 inches, made of metal with glass windows so the tracks could be photographed. The chamber could be synchronised with the accelerator beam: a photograph was taken, and the chamber was recompressed in time for the next pulse.
The programme was very large. It involved dozens of physicists and graduate students, hundreds of engineers and technicians, millions of photographs, and computer systems to measure and analyse the tracks. It revealed whole families of new particles and resonance states, which are particles that exist only for a fleeting moment before decaying.
For this work he received the 1968 Nobel Prize in Physics, cited for his decisive contributions to elementary particle physics, in particular the discovery of a large number of resonant states, made possible through his development of the hydrogen bubble chamber technique and data analysis. He is remembered as one of the great experimenters of the twentieth century, as much for his skill in organising large teams as for any single idea.
Unusual investigations
In the mid-1960s Alvarez turned to projects well outside particle physics. In 1964 he proposed what became known as the High Altitude Particle Physics Experiment, or HAPPE. It was originally conceived as a large superconducting magnet carried aloft by a balloon to study very high-energy interactions. Over time its goals shifted towards cosmology and the part played by particles and radiation in the early universe. The project used detectors carried by high-altitude balloons and by U-2 aircraft, and it was an early forerunner of the experiments on the cosmic microwave background later carried out by the COBE satellite.
In 1965 he proposed a method called muon tomography to search the Egyptian pyramids for unknown chambers. Muons are particles produced by cosmic rays that can pass through rock. The plan was to place spark chambers, a type of particle detector, under the Pyramid of Khafre, near a known chamber, and count the cosmic rays arriving from different directions. A hidden void in the stone would change the count in its direction. Alvarez assembled a team of physicists and archaeologists from the United States and Egypt. The work was interrupted by the Six-Day War of 1967, resumed afterwards and continued until 1969, when he reported to the American Physical Society that no hidden chambers had been found in the 19 percent of the pyramid that had been surveyed.
Another much-discussed episode was his analysis of the Zapruder film, shot in 1963 during the assassination of John F. Kennedy. Alvarez, an expert in optics and photographic analysis, studied the motion of the president's head. He argued, both in theory and in experiments, that the backward motion after the shot was consistent with a shot fired from behind, an explanation he called the jet effect. Other researchers later refined and supported that account. He also examined the timing of the shots, the shock wave that affected the camera, and the speed of the camera, and pointed out errors and omissions in the analyses by the FBI. The subject remains controversial, but his work is often cited as an example of rigorous method applied to a field far from his own.
The extinction of the dinosaurs
During the 1970s his son, the geologist Walter Alvarez, was studying rocks in central Italy, where a gorge exposed limestone layers above and below the boundary between the Cretaceous and Paleogene periods. That boundary marks the end of the age of the dinosaurs. At the boundary lay a thin layer of clay. Walter wanted to know what the clay meant, and he needed to measure very rare elements in it. He turned to his father, who had access to the nuclear chemists at the Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory.
Frank Asaro and Helen Michel used neutron activation analysis, a technique in which a sample is bombarded with neutrons so that its atoms emit characteristic radiation. This reveals which elements are present and in what amounts. They found the clay contained iridium at levels far above those normal in Earth's crust. The metal is scarce at the surface of our planet but common in certain meteorites.
In 1980 Luis Alvarez, Walter Alvarez, Asaro and Michel published a paper proposing that the extinction at the end of the Cretaceous was caused by the impact of an asteroid or comet. The idea explained the iridium. Over the following years, soot, glassy spherules, quartz showing shock deformation and microscopic diamonds were also reported from the same layer, all associated with violent impacts.
The proposal drew strong criticism from geologists, and the scientific debate was sometimes bitter. About ten years after Alvarez's death, evidence of a large impact crater was found off the Yucatán Peninsula in Mexico, which supported the theory. Other researchers also found that the extinction may have been rapid in geological terms, taking thousands of years rather than millions. Alternative explanations exist, including intense volcanic activity at the Deccan Traps, but the impact theory remains the dominant one among specialists.
Aviation, family and final years
Alvarez liked to say that he had two separate careers, one in science and one in aviation, and that he found them almost equally rewarding. He learned to fly in 1933, later earned instrument and multi-engine ratings, and over roughly fifty years logged more than a thousand hours, most of them as pilot in command. Besides GCA, he held the basic patent for the radar transponder, which he assigned to the United States government for one dollar. He served on advisory committees on civil air navigation and air traffic control, and on a study of how the scientific community could help the country fight a non-nuclear war.
His flying brought many episodes. While working on GCA he became the first civilian to make an approach with his view outside the cockpit blocked. He flew many military aircraft from the co-pilot's seat, including a B-29 and a Lockheed F-104 Starfighter. During the war he survived a crash as a passenger in a Miles Master.
In his personal life he married Geraldine Smithwick in 1936, in a chapel at the University of Chicago. They had two children, Walter and Jean, and divorced in 1957. On December 28, 1958, he married Janet L. Landis, and they had two more children, Donald and Helen. He was a member of the JASON defence advisory group and of the Bohemian Club, a private society in San Francisco.
In his last years he suffered from esophageal cancer and underwent a series of operations. He died on September 1, 1988, in Berkeley, California. His ashes were scattered over Monterey Bay, and his papers are held at The Bancroft Library of the University of California, Berkeley. He had been named professor emeritus in 1978.
His legacy is twofold. There is the experimental work, from the study of K-electron capture to the bubble chamber, and his ability to lead large teams. There are also systems that remain in everyday use in various forms, such as transponders and ground-guided landing. His name is linked to the impact theory that explained the disappearance of the dinosaurs, and an asteroid, 3581 Alvarez, is named after him and his son. He also appears as a character, played by Alex Wolff, in the 2023 film Oppenheimer.
Quotes
“There is no democracy in physics. We cannot say that any second-rate author has as much right to an opinion as Fermi.”
“In my considered opinion the peer review system, in which the proposals rather than the proposers are reviewed, is the greatest disaster to be visited upon the scientific community in this century”
Main contributions
- 1937Observation of K-electron capture: a nuclear process predicted by theory, first detected with a specially built Geiger counter.
- 1940Measurement of the neutron's magnetic moment with Felix Bloch, a gauge of the strength of its tiny internal magnet.
- 1946Linear proton accelerator, built between 1946 and 1947 to speed particles along a straight line.
- 1965Proposal to search the Pyramid of Khafre for hidden chambers using cosmic-ray muons.
- 1968Liquid hydrogen bubble chamber, which revealed families of particles and resonance states and earned him the Nobel Prize.
- 1980Alvarez hypothesis: an asteroid impact caused the extinction of the non-avian dinosaurs.
- Ground Controlled Approach radar, which guides aircraft to the runway by radio instructions even in bad weather.
Teachers and students
Studied under:
Taught:
Trivia and anecdotes
A submarine fooled
The VIXEN system sent a signal whose strength grew with the cube of the distance, so a submarine believed the plane was moving away and did not dive.
A character in a novel
Arthur C. Clarke, whom Alvarez met in England during the war, drew on the experience for his novel Glide Path, which contains a thinly disguised version of him.
A flight that found nothing
The aircraft that flew over Germany to detect xenon-133 found nothing, because the Germans had not built a reactor capable of a chain reaction.
Their contemporaries
While Luis Walter Alvarez was alive (1911–1988)…
Alive at the same time
Discovered or invented in those years
- 1916Black holeA region of space where gravity is so strong that nothing, not even light, can escape once it crosses a certain boundary.
- 1925TelevisionA system that sends moving pictures and sound over distance and shows them on a receiver, the television set.
- 1925Quantum mechanicsPhysical theory describing how matter and light behave at atomic and subatomic scales, where energy is exchanged in minimal packets and results are expressed as probabilities.
- 1931Big BangA cosmological model describing how the universe expanded from an early state of extreme density and temperature, about 13.8 billion years ago.
- 1945ComputerA programmable machine that takes in data, processes it by following stored instructions, and produces results, able to switch tasks simply by running different software.
- 1969InternetA global network of interconnected computer networks that communicate using the TCP/IP protocol suite.
Lev Landau1908–1968 · Physics
Hideki Yukawa1907–1981 · Physics
Maria Göppert Mayer1906–1972 · Physics
Hans Bethe1906–2005 · Physics
Richard Feynman1918–1988 · Physics
J. Robert Oppenheimer1904–1967 · Physics